Need A Plan For The Holidays? Download “The Gift of the Magi” Short Story Unit

The Gift of the Magi Christmas Short Story UnitDo you need an interactive, student-centered service learning project that will encourage middle and high school students to turn their Christmas break excitement into a creative endeavor based on O. Henry's “The Gift of the Magi”? This unit is full of highly engaging student discussions perfect for Christmas and encouraging students to think beyond themselves to how they can help others.

This 3-6 day lesson contains everything you need to guide students through reading and viewing short literature covering topics relevant to students today, responding to a daily essential question, and planning and creating real-world children's books or videos witih a modern take on a classic tale of love and sacrifice.

This short story resource is designed to help students analyze a complex work of literary fiction. Specific questions presented in an assessment practice worksheet guide students through the process of analyzing the plot, characterization, setting, and theme.

This lesson plan includes:

  1. Teacher preparation instructions
  2. During teaching instructions
  3. Student assessment practice
  4. Theme Notes
  5. Analysis prompts
  6. Answer key
  7. Service learning creative writing project

Download this unit at Teachers Pay Teachers, or right here in the reThink ELA Shop.

Note: On November 27 & 28 ONLY: save 20% in my TpT store by using the code CYBER17 at checkout!

About the author 

Michelle Boyd Waters, M.Ed.

Michelle Boyd Waters is the founder of reThink ELA, where she creates research-informed resources that help middle and high school English teachers build stronger communities of readers and writers. After teaching secondary English for 10 years, Michelle has continued working alongside educators and students as a university composition instructor, writing center director, teacher consultant for the Oklahoma Writing Project, and mentor to new teachers. Her work brings together classroom experience, literacy research, and writing center pedagogy to create practical resources that support authentic reading, meaningful writing, and student voice. Through reThink ELA, she helps teachers create classrooms where both students and educators can thrive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    1. Hi Julie!

      I think with some scaffolding in terms of additional discussions of vocabulary, perhaps reading the story to the class, and maybe creating a framework for the subsequent short story the students will create (or even working as a class to create a modern version of the tale), you would be able to teach this at the fifth grade level.

      Thank you for asking!

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}